Back to the Basics with Tax Records: Part 2
What kind of tax records exist? That’s what I want to share today in the second post in our back to basics with tax records series. The first post, by Diana, gave you a taste of what tax records may contain and how you can use them in your research to determine identity and relationships. Hopefully now you’re convinced of their usefulness. Tax records might be especially helpful when you’re facing a tough problem like a burned county or when you are performing reasonably exhaustive research. Let’s discuss what types of tax records exist. Part 3 (coming out next week) will be about how to find tax records.
Types of Tax Records
During the colonial period in the United States, you may see tax records by other names, like the following:
Quitrents: records of property taxes paid to a proprietor or the crown (colonial time period) – read more: Quit Rents of Virginia, 1704
Tithable: person who was able to be taxed (in colonial Virginia, and English law) – read more: Tithables at the Library of Virginia
Typical U.S. Tax Types
Most United States tax records will fall into one of these three categories:
Head/Poll Tax: also known as head tax or capitation tax – tax on each “head” or person, regardless of their personal property
Real Property Tax: paid by people who owned land
Personal Property Tax: paid by people who owned livestock, slaves, carriages, stud horses, and other taxed property (defined locally)
Many other tax records were collected in various localities over the years. You might see the following types of tax records: poor tax, roads, faculty, inheritance, title/deed, ecclesiastical, business, liquor, federal tax on aliens, old age assistance, etc. Learn more about different types of tax records with this great book – The Genealogist’s Guide to Researching Tax Records, by Carol Cooke Darrow, CG and Susan Winchester, Ph.D., C.P.A.  (This is an affiliate link. Thank for your support!)
Example of Poll Taxes
While the example discussed below is a tax list combining both poll taxes and property taxes, it is a great example of how poll taxes can be a substitute for census records, because they include all the men within a certain age range, not just landowners.
I used tax records extensively in a recent client project to identify John Johnson, the father of Harris Johnson, among several John Johnsons in Rowan County, North Carolina. I learned much about the value of tax records and how they can be used as evidence. Within Rowan County, there were about 10-15 tax lists, each for a different neighborhood called a “company.” Each year, I found that sevearl of the companies had a man named John Johnson. I wanted to know which one was John Johnson of Cabin Creek. I traced each John Johnson by grouping him with his neighbors. I identified the men by the neighbors listed in the same tax company, usually about 40-80 men.
For example, when John Johnson’s son, Randal, was old enough to be included in the poll tax, I knew right away for that year which John was John Johnson of Cabin Creek. I already had the will for John Johnson of Cabin Creek where he names his children and describes his land. Here is an example from the 1802 Rowan County Tax Book, Captain Ellis Company, showing both John Johnson and Randal Johnson. 
Randal was taxed for 1 white poll and John was taxed for 100 acres of land and 1 white poll.
Tax records can give clues about the age of a person being taxed. Originally, North Carolina laws regulating taxable polls (or heads) stipulated that males age 16 and older were taxable. In 1784, the law was changed so that only males over 21 were taxable. In 1801, the law was changed again to exempt men over age 50. In 1817, the age of 50 was lowered to 45.  From this 1802 tax list, then, I can deduce that John and Randal were between the ages of 21 and 50.
Before Randal was old enough to be taxed, I identified John Johnson by transcribing each tax list and becoming familiar with his neighbor’s names. I began to recognize neighbors named Benjamin Davis, Clemment Lanier, Lewis Lanier, William Badget, Alexander Smith, and William Kinney. This cluster proved invaluable to identifying the correct John Johnson. Later, I learned that Benjamin Davis was John Johnson’s son-in-law, and William Kinney’s was probably the father of John Johnson’s daughter-in-law, Jane Kinney. I found the marriage of Abraham Johnson to Jane Kinney in Abraham Johnson’s War of 1812 Pension and Bounty Land Warrant application file. 
The tax records for the period of 1800-1807 were invaluable for separating John Johnson of Cabin Creek from the other John Johnsons.
Example of Combined Tax Record
This is a tax record created by Cass County, Texas in 1855. This is a good example of real property (land) tax, personal property tax, and poll taxes all being combined into one record. In the image above, you can see the left portion of the page, including columns for Real Property – Land and Town Lots. In the image below, you can see the right side of the page, including columns for Personal Property – Negroes, Horses, Cattle, Money at Interest, merchandise on hand 1st January, miscellaneous property. The value of all this property was then added up. The poll tax was in the next column. Then the total tax was calculated to pay to the state and to the county.
My relative appears lower on the page. He was not taxed for any real property or personal property, just the poll (head) tax, as you can see in the image below:
Isenhour, Moses W. [poll tax] 50 cents [state tax] 50 cents [county tax] 25 cents 
The tax records from 1853-1858 in Cass County, Texas, are direct evidence of Moses Isenhour’s residence. When I was performing this research, learning about Moses’ residence in Cass County cast doubt onto my hypothesis that he served in an Arkansas regiment in the Civil War. But when I completed the research, I learned that Moses migrated from Montgomery County, Arkansas, to Cass, Texas, then returned to Montgomery. Moses’ wife Amanda remained in Cass. In fact, she appears on the Cass County tax list in his place from 1859-1869. Amanda Isenhour and their children are enumerated on the 1860 Federal Census in Cass County. Moses is not enumerated anywhere on the 1860 census, at least that I could locate.
Learning about Moses Isenhour’s migration from Akransas to Texas and then back to Arkansas was very important in identifying his Civil War service. Typically, a man’s residence in 1860 is a big clue to which regiment they joined. I found two Civil War service records for men named Moses Isenhour. One in Bosque County, Texas, and one in Montgomery, Arkansas. The man who lived in Bosque County, Texas, was married to a different woman and was buried in Missouri.
I learned that Moses Isenhour of Cass County was elected as coroner of Montgomery County, Arkansas in 1860. His brother Valentine still lived there, so he probably returned there in about 1859-1860, leaving his wife and children in Cass County, where Amanda is found on the tax lists instead. In 1861, Moses enlisted in the Confederate army, serving in the 11th Arkansas Infantry. He died in 1862. A biography in Texas Under Many Flags: Texas biography about William Martin Isenhour, son of Moses, confirms that the family did move to Cass County, and their father returned to Montgomery, served in the Confederacy, and died soon after. The biography also mentions that Moses was an overseer for a number of the largest slave-owners in the state. 
As you can see, tax records can be extremely helpful identifying the residence of a person in between census years, or when they are completely missing from one of the federal census years.
Join me next week to learn all about how to find tax records!
_ Carol Cooke Darrow and Susan Winchester, The Genealogist’s Guide to Researching Tax Records (Westminster: Heritage Books, 2003) 23.  Rowan County, North Carolina, 1802 Tax Book, Capt Ellis Co. List, unpaginated, lines 24-25, entry for John Johnson and Randel Johnson; “Tax records (Rowan County, North Carolina), 1758-1892,” image online, DGS 8151623, image 45; FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org : accessed 17 November 2018); citing FHL microfilm #1760528.  State Library of North Carolina, “Tax Records in North Carolina: NC Tax Records,” (http://statelibrary.ncdcr.libguides.com : accessed 13 November 2018).  “War of 1812 Pension and Bounty Land Warrant Application Files,” database and images, Fold3 (https://www.fold3.com/image/1/314586309 : accessed 19 November 2018); image of declaration of surviving soldier for pension for pension 25568, service of Abraham Johnson (Private, Capt. Jacob Krider’s Co. N.C. Mil); citing “War of 1812 Pension and Bounty land Warrant Application Files, compiled ca. 1871–1900, documenting the period 1812–ca.1900,” National Archives Catalog ID: 564415, Record Group 15, Roll RG15-1812PB-Bx1874, National Archives, Washington, D.C.  Moses Isenhower, 1855, Cass County, “Texas, County Tax Rolls, 1837-1910,” database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 11 Nov 2017), image 16; citing State Archives, Austin.  Clarence Ray Wharton, “William Martin Isenhower, Texas Under Many Flags: Texas biography (Chicago: American Historical Society, 1930), vol 3, 167-168; image copy, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 24 March 2018), digital image 660 of 1350; citing FHL microfilm 1000594.